The Absurd Netflix Dark Comedy That Has You Rooting For The Villain

By Sckylar Gibby-Brown | Updated

Rosamund Pike in I Care A Lot

Who doesn’t love a good and twisted dark comedy? If you’re in the mood for adding something new to your movie list, let us suggest I Care A Lot, a Netflix original comedy and thriller film that will somehow have you care a lot about the villain.

A Netflix original, I Care A Lot mixes thriller and comedy into a film that’s thought-provoking and amusing in equal measure.

In the realm of twisted tales that blur the lines between hero and villain, this Netflix flick emerges as a strikingly provocative offering, a darkly satirical thriller that revels in its morally ambiguous characters and biting commentary on late-stage capitalism.

Written and directed by J Blakeson, the film presents a world where guardianship becomes a sinister game, and the vulnerable elderly are nothing more than assets to be seized. With a stellar cast led by Rosamund Pike, Peter Dinklage, and Eiza González, I Care A Lot takes viewers on a roller-coaster journey through deceit, danger, and the ultimate question of who we can truly trust.

At the heart of Netflix’s I Care A Lot is Marla Grayson (Rosamund Pike), a cunning con artist who manipulates the legal system to become the court-appointed guardian of elderly individuals. Under her sinister care, these unsuspecting elders are stripped of their autonomy and assets while Marla and her accomplices rake in the profits.

Eiza Gonzalez, Dianne West, and Rosamund Pike in I Care A Lot

The story takes a spine-tingling turn when Marla sets her sights on Jennifer Peterson (Dianne Wiest), a seemingly defenseless retiree who harbors a mysterious secret, and encounters an unexpected adversary in the form of Roman Lunyov (Peter Dinklage), a powerful crime lord with a personal vendetta.

This Netflix film opens a window into Marla’s cutthroat world, where empathy is a liability and compassion a rare commodity. Rosamund Pike shines as Marla, portraying her with a chilling charm that oscillates between captivating and repulsive. Pike’s ability to embody a character in  I Care A Lot that’s simultaneously detestable and alluring is a testament to both her acting prowess and the words penned by Blakeson.

I Care A Lot is not based on a single true story, but the plot is based on the rising number of scams targetting the elderly.

Peter Dinklage brings his signature gravitas to the role of Roman in this Netflix feature, infusing the character with layers of complexity. As a crime lord with a personal connection to Jennifer, Dinklage adds an air of unpredictability to I Care A Lot’s narrative.

Eiza González shines as Fran, Marla’s partner-in-crime and lover, injecting a touch of vulnerability into the otherwise calculating world of guardianship exploitation. Dianne Wiest, known for her versatile roles, delivers a poignant portrayal of Jennifer Peterson, a character whose layers unravel as the story unfolds.

I Care A Lot thrives on its crisp pacing, keeping the audience on edge with its tense plot developments. The film seamlessly transitions between dark comedy and heart-pounding thriller, creating a balance that allows viewers to simultaneously root for and question the motives of its characters.

Blakeson’s direction in this Netflix feature showcases his ability to manipulate tone and tension, drawing the audience into a labyrinth of deception and danger.

Peter Dinklage in I Care A Lot

I Care A Lot made its world premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival, garnering attention for its audacious storytelling and standout performances. The film’s later release on Netflix further solidified its status as a must-watch, allowing audiences worldwide to delve into its twisted world of legal manipulation and moral ambiguity.

In the end, I Care A Lot leaves a lasting impression as a thought-provoking exploration of morality in a world driven by self-interest.

The reception to I Care A Lot has been polarizing, reflecting the provocative nature of its themes and characters. Critics have praised the Netflix film’s darkly comedic tone and Rosamund Pike’s riveting performance, which earned her the Golden Globe for Best Actress in a Motion Picture – Comedy or Musical. Some critics lauded the film’s audacity in tackling issues of greed, power, and deception within a capitalist society.

Conversely, others found fault with I Care A Lot’s treatment of its elderly characters and its willingness to push the boundaries of tastelessness. While the narrative invites Netflix viewers to empathize with Marla’s cunning, it also raises questions about the line between anti-hero and outright villain.

In the end, I Care A Lot leaves a lasting impression as a thought-provoking exploration of morality in a world driven by self-interest. Rosamund Pike’s tour de force performance, paired with J Blakeson’s bold direction, creates a cinematic experience that is as unsettling as it is riveting.

By forcing viewers to confront uncomfortable truths about society’s treatment of the vulnerable and the ethics of power, the film challenges preconceived notions and will leave viewers asking questions long after the credits roll.