13

Matt Smith Already Quitting On Doctor Who?

When David Tennant left Doctor Who, it almost tore me apart. His final episode as The Doctor left me in a weepy wreck. Then, against all odds, they managed to find someone new to play The Doctor who was almost as good. I’m not going to try and tell you the current season of Doctor Who is even half as good as Tennant’s years in the Tardis, but blame that on writing and not Smith, who’s absolutely brilliant.

He’s only been at it for a single season and things are really just settling in. So of course he’s going to quit and put us through the misery of Tennant’s departure all over again. Maybe.

The Sun claims 27-year Smith plans to abandon the series after his second season as the character in pursuit of a film career. It should however be noted that this news comes from one of the most unreliable sources on the planet. That leaves plenty of room to believe this is completely untrue.

Besides, how well is that “leaving Doctor Who for a film career” working out for David Tennant? Not very well. And with all due respect to Matt Smith, Tennant had ten times the heat he’ll have if he leaves after only two seasons, one of which suffered from mediocre writing. It doesn’t seem logical.

But while we’re on the subject, what is it with the BBC and their inability to lock anyone up for a long term contract? Here in America we’ve managed to keep Steve Carell churning out episodes of The Office for nearly a decade, even though he already has a wildly successful film career and could probably make a lot more money if he left. In the UK, it’s a minor miracle if they manage to keep a Doctor for more than two seasons. Someone should introduce them to long term contracts. If we can’t have David Tennant, I don’t want Matt Smith going anywhere.

Comments

  • Fseabrook1971

    Mediocre writing? I disagree with you on that. If anything, the season was better for not having the OTT stories that RTD favoured. This season returned to the good old classic stories of old.

    • http://www.giantfreakinrobot.com JT

      Nah it’s been very mediocre man. None of the highs of the previous seasons.

    • http://www.cinemablend.com JT

      Good old classic stories without heart.

      They're not bad, but it's never reached the writing highs of some of the previous seasons at their very best.

  • Fseabrook1971

    Oh, and Smith *was* locked up to a long term contract. He signed for three years with an option to extend to five if he wanted to and the Beeb wanted to keep him.

    • http://www.giantfreakinrobot.com JT

      Apparently they aren’t enforcing those very strictly.

    • http://www.cinemablend.com JT

      Apparently they don't take their long term contracts very seriously in the UK then.

  • TenFan

    Um, can we wait until some of the movies Tennant has been working on are actually released or shown, before we decide his movie career isn't working out?

    • http://www.cinemablend.com JT

      Nope. It isn't. So far. The movies he's working on aren't anything of note or he has a minor role in them. I'm not any happier about it than you are. Hopefully things get better soon.

      • Tomh1138

        @JT: I read somewhere (can't remember where) that RTD talked Tennant into leaving at the same time as him, so that it would be more dramatic. So even though he said that he left to pursue movies, that may be only part of it.

        I wish Tennant had stayed for 5 years. That being said, to reiterate what I said earlier, Matt Smith is really good, and I'm glad to hear that he'll be around for a while.

  • Tomh1138

    Completely disagree on the quality of this season. Many of the episodes were home runs, and even the lesser ones had a solid level of quality in them. The other seasons had train wrecks like “Love and Monsters” and that 2-parter with the pig people in the 1930s. This one had amazing episodes like “Vincent and the Doctor,” the “Angels” 2-parter, “Amy's Choice,” etc.

    Yes, David Tennant is the best. And, yes, Matt Smith is a surprisingly good follow-up. But to call the season “mediocre”? Sorry, can't agree with that!

  • Newsome

    The chick that plays Amy already said he wasnt planning on quitting. Christ do you really believe the Sun of all tabloids?

  • HumorousUsername234

    Christopher Eccleston got only one Series of Doctor Who, three episodes of which heavily involved farting aliens. Even if this turns out to be true (which I doubt), I'd still probably have a wee bit more pity for him than Matt, who in my opinion was given a pretty solid series, with lows about on the level of RTD's Doctor Who (Cold Blood/The Hungry Earth, Victory of the Daleks) and highs slightly higher (Amy's Choice, The Angels two-parter, the finale, and… oh yeah, AMY'S CHOICE).

    • Tomh1138

      @Humorous: Eccleston only wanted to do one season, to work with RTD. He didn't want to go on beyond that.