8

Karen Gillan Says She Wants Amy Pond To Be Killed On Doctor Who

Doctor Who’s Karen Gillan said recently that she wants her character, Amy Pond, to die on the show. This would mark the first death of a companion on screen, and would put finality on her character in a way others never get. Even Rose still lives on and could feasibly return to the Doctor’s life, except she belongs forever to the 10th Doctor; just as Amy belongs to the 11th Doctor.

I can understand Gillan’s desire to differentiate her character from the slew of companions. She’s made a huge impact on the show, and has been a major reason that we accepted Matt Smith so quickly. Amelia Pond is by far my favorite of the main companions, but I’ll admit that the Rose/Tennant relationship is far sweeter. On her own though, Amy can’t be beat. Lately I’ve come to think of Rory, Amy’s husband, as the Doctor’s new companion. I wonder if Rory would stick with the Doctor if Amy died, especially as it would somehow have to be the Doctor’s fault.

Karen’s comments on her wanting Amy Pond to die are very brief. All signs point to Amy’s run ending on the show, and I’d be happy to see Rory or someone new take up the task. I’m not opposed to such a momentous event as Amy’s death happening, and I think it could lead to a fantastic self-examination by the Doctor. Perhaps something like this could lead the 11th Doctor to finally confront the “Who?” question.

Comments

  • tigerchanter

    Amy would not be the first Companion to die. Are you forgetting about Adric?

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adric

    • http://profiles.google.com/cliff1969 Cliff Hesby

       And Sara Kingdom before him.

    • http://www.facebook.com/people/Sara-E-James/170101031 Sara E. James

      He said “on screen.” Did Adric die on screen?

  • http://twitter.com/crey_zee Crey Zee

    ….also, “Even Rose still lives on and could feasibly return to the Doctor’s life, except she belongs forever to the 10th Doctor; just as Amy belongs to the 11th Doctor.” Rose first appeared with the 9th Doctor? orever to the 10th Doctor; just as Amy belongs to the 11th Doctor.Even Rose still lives on and could feasibly return to the Doctor’s life, except she belongs forever to the 10th Doctor; just as Amy belongs to the 11th Doctor.

  • Eternalgreenknight

    She could be a catalyst to make 11th remorseful about it- so much so that he goes back to 10th and changes the timeline, and with the help of the 10th forestalls the change, fixes things, and disappears so Tennant can come back for a few more seasons (I mean, come on, he is great at the role), before Smith takes over again in the future.

  • the buddha kitten

    On the alternative earth there’s Rose and the other tenth doctor surely?  Yes he’s human rather than a time lord with two hearts but he is still the Doctor, with all his memories and knowlege. Also where is the actual Doctor of that alternative earth? There must be one and since Rose never existed on that world it would be the ninth Doctor, who never had her as his assistant and therefore never had to sacrifice himself to save her, so never had to regenerate. So both Ecclestone and Tennant exist as Doctors there…its a thought….

  • Jwsbaker

    Her death would suck, but perhaps it would make a good plot device, and we’d see some great introspection by The Doctor.

  • Richard

    I’m very excited about the possibility of bringing back Rose so they can kill her.